| |
| |
| Topic |
Rating
(% of Time) |
Judge or Commissioner is not prepared to hear the case (Has not reviewed pleadings)
|
Over 90% |
Judge or Commissioner issues orders however doesn't enforce them (This causes significant conflict and induces significant delays)
|
Over 90% |
Judge or Commissioner orders attorneys and their clients to meet and confer but one side will not cooperate... Then does nothing to drive cooperation... (This causes significant conflict and induces significant delays)
|
Over 90% |
Judge or Commissioner months to deal with TRO (This takes the accused's rights away and gives unfair control of everything to the accuser)
|
Over 50% |
When a Judge or Commissioner makes a mistake it rarely gets fixed (This causes one of the litigants to file motion after motion to fix the problem... However it rarely gets fixed)
|
Over 80% |
|
| |
Relevant Documents:
2002 Audit of the Marin Family Court
Click Here to Download a PDF of the 67 Page Audit
Recommendations for Improving Public Trust & Confidence:
Analysis of Trial Court Plans and AOC Strategic Projects
Click Here to Download a PDF of the 50 Page Report
Findings on Judge Michael Dufficy, Commissioner Sylvia Shapiro, & Court-Appointees in Marin County's Superior Court in California
Written by Karen Winner
February 28, 2000
Click Here to Download a PDF of the 54 Page Report
|
| |
|
|
| |
| FORM_NAME |
|
Name of Award |
Amount |
| Arrest |
|
City of San Diego |
399,980.00 |
| Arrest |
|
Contra Costa County |
1,317,924.00 |
| Arrest |
|
County of Marin |
400,000.00 |
| Arrest |
|
County of Shasta |
382,185.00 |
| Arrest |
|
Hoopa Valley Tribe |
197,284.00 |
| Arrest |
|
Solano County |
400,000.00 |
| Campus |
|
Cal Poly Pomona Foundation, Inc |
199,922.00 |
| Campus |
|
California State University, Long Beach Foundation |
200,000.00 |
| Campus |
|
Regents of University of California, Berkley |
199,690.00 |
| Campus |
|
Stanford University |
213,814.00 |
| Campus |
|
University of Southern California |
397,641.00 |
| Coalition |
|
California Alliance Against Domestic Violence |
83,041.00 |
| Coalition |
|
California Coalition Against Sexual Assault |
83,041.00 |
| LAV |
|
Asian Pacific Islander Legal Outreach |
600,000.00 |
| LAV |
|
Bay Area Legal Aid |
675,000.00 |
| LAV |
|
Catholic Charities of the Diocese of Stockton |
450,000.00 |
| LAV |
|
Law Foundation of Silicon Valley |
350,000.00 |
| LAV |
|
Los Angeles Commission on Assaults Against Women |
350,000.00 |
| LAV |
|
Santa Clara County Asian Law Alliance |
332,802.00 |
| LAV |
|
YWCA of San Diego County |
449,998.00 |
| STOP Formula |
|
CA Governor's Office of Emergency Services- Law Enforcement and Victim Services Division |
11,429,859.00 |
| Safe Havens |
|
Contra Costa County |
349,811.00 |
| Safe Havens |
|
Santa Clara County |
349,868.00 |
| Stop VAIW |
|
Shingle Springs Rancheria |
150,000.00 |
| Stop VAIW |
|
Two Feathers Native American Family Services |
201,187.00 |
| Technical Assistance |
|
Asian Women's Shelter |
400,000.00 |
| Technical Assistance |
|
Family Violence Prevention Fund |
750,000.00 |
| Technical Assistance |
|
Tribal Law and Policy Institute |
150,000.00 |
| Technical Assistance |
|
Tribal Law and Policy Institute |
400,000.00 |
| Technical Assistance |
|
Tribal Law and Policy Institute |
100,000.00 |
| Training |
|
Marin County |
443,975.00 |
| Transitional Housing |
|
Center for Community Solutions |
350,000.00 |
| Transitional Housing |
|
Family Services of Tulare County |
233,682.00 |
| Tribal |
|
Stop the Violence Coalition, Inc |
699,760.00 |
| |
|
TOTAL |
23,690,464.00 |
| |
|
TOTAL (ALL STATES) |
|
| |
|
% OF TOTAL FOR CALIFORNIA |
7.1% |
|
| |
| How many of the Separated are involved in a high conflict divorce? |
? |
|
| How many others are actively seeking divorce? |
? |
|
How many families are engaged in high conflict divorces?
- What percentage of the people know what they are getting into?
- How long are these divorces litigated?
- 1 year
- 2 years
- 3 years
- 4 years
- 5 years
- 10 years
- How many are driving for a win at all costs?
- What is the fall out of these high conflict divorces?
- How many families are left with any resources?
- Who benefits? (or do we really know who benefits? Certainly not the families.)
- Who decides what is in the best interest of the children?
- The judge
- The therapist
- The custody evaluator
- The attorney
- DCS
- Are all court officials created equal?
- Do court officials have the time to pay attention to the details?
- Do court officials follow due process?
- Do court officials study the case before they hear arguments and make decisions?
- Do court officials use judicial discretion appropriately?
- Is there a standard for judicial discretion?
- What percentage of the families are better off after the divorce than before?
- What percentage of the families have something left at the end of the divorce?
- What is the "Divorce Industry" doing to solve the problems that arise from high conflict divorces?
- Is there corruption in our courts and if so how many families are effected?
|
? |
|
| How many children of Divorced families commit a crime? |
? |
|
| How many children of Divorced families get involved with Drugs? |
? |
|
| How many children of Divorced families get involved with gangs? |
? |
|
| How many children of Divorced families are jailed for life? |
? |
|
What is the cost to society when wrong decisions are made in family court?
|
? |
|
What percentage of Divorces Are Filed with a Restraining Order?
- How many of these restraining orders are really necessary?
- How many of these restraining orders are obtained to get control of assets?
- How long does it take to litigate a restraining order?
- One week?
- One Month?
- Six Months?
- One Year?
- Two Years?
- Do restraining orders benefit the court or county?
- Are individuals' rights violated when one is issued?
- Is there a different criteria used to issue restrained order when the accused doesn't have a record of abuse or any altercation with the law?
|
? |
|
Is DCSS providing a benefit to society?
- If a parent wishes to pay support but can't because of faulty orders from family court?
- If a parent wishes to pay support but can't because family court imputed income beyond the parent's current earning capacity?
- If parent wishes to pay support but can't because of circumstances beyond their control... Who would benefit if that parent's driver's license was suspended?
- Is 10% interest rate appropriate for back support?
- Is the county benefiting by ordering and collecting more support?
- Does the county loose money if it finds that it ordered support in error?
|
? |
|
| How much money is the county collecting on issuance of Restraining orders? |
? |
|
|
|
|